1849 Sylvester Hayner
1850 Sylvester Hayner
1851 Sylvester Hayner
1855 Daniel N. VanPelt, 3 years; James H. Rice, 1 year
1856 James H. Rice
1857 B. B. Wool
1860 Charles C. Baxter
1865 C. W. Way, Rep.
1868 James G. Mott, Rep.
1869 Alanson P. Chase
1870 Dexter Groesbeck, Dem.
1871 Ed. Lansing, Rep.
1872 John Filkins
1879 George Freiot, Albert Filkins
1882 Hiram See, Rep.
1886 W. G. P. Campbell
1887 Charles D. Sterm